This Is The Only Number That Can “Switch Off” The Bull Market

The stock market has enjoyed quite a run since Election Day. But even before Donald Trump surprised the world and won the U.S. presidency, stocks were on an epic run that began in March 2009 at the depths of the Great Financial Crisis. The most impressive aspect of this bull market is that it defied the worst economic recovery in the last century and survived eight years of Obama administration policies that were hostile to economic growth and markets.

Rather than building on a solid economic foundation, the bull market benefited from zero interest rates, lower corporate tax payments, wage suppression and financial engineering in the form of epic levels of debt-funded M&A, stock buybacks and dividend increases. These factors have little if anything to do with the fundamental financial condition of American corporations.

Eight years later, this leaves the markets (which really means the individual companies comprising it) overvalued and overindebted.

The only important question for investors, however, is not where the market has been but where it is going. The answer to that question lies in whether the serious valuation, growth and debt headwinds facing stocks are more powerful than a set of structural forces that developed over the past two decades that pushed stock prices to extremely high valuation levels today – as high as we’ve seen in the last one hundred years.

Here’s why we’re being inexorably sucked into a bull market right now.

And here’s the only thing that can stop it…

This Bull Market Is Fueled By A Massive Power Imbalance

The most powerful structural force at work is an enormous amount of money pursuing a diminishing number of investment opportunities in U.S. stocks.

There are roughly half as many publicly listed companies trading on US stock exchanges today than 20 years ago. The peak of 7,322 public stocks was reached in 1996; by late 2015 the number dropped to 3,700.

The primary reason for the decline is massive M&A activity that removed many public companies from the mix; lesser reasons include the cumulative effects of private equity firms taking over public companies and a steady slowing of IPO activity. Heavier regulation on public companies such as the Sarbanes-Oxley Act passed in the wake of the Enron scandal, which significantly increased the costs of being a public company, also contributed to more companies staying private. All of these factors contributed to serious shrinkage in the number of publicly listed companies over the last twenty years.

While the number of listed companies shrunk, thousands of new ETFs sprung up to take their place. But ETFs do not create new investment opportunities; they merely repackage existing ones. As a result, they magnify the shrinkage of available stocks by funneling more money into the limited number available. Stocks included in the most popular and largest ETFs attract more capital than those excluded from such ETFs without regard to their investment fundamentals. This inflates their values beyond what their fundamentals suggests is justified. This is how you get an overvalued market, which is what we have. But it is also how markets can stay overvalued for long periods of time.

But this is only half of the picture. The other half involves the fact that there is much more money in the world today chasing this diminishing number of investment opportunities.

While the number of stocks dropped in half over the last twenty years, the amount of money available to invest in them exploded as a result of unprecedented efforts by central bankers to revive economic growth. These efforts accelerated after the 2008 financial crisis to the point where the world is now home to more than $200 trillion of non-financial sector debt.

The latest figure provided by the International Monetary Fund is $217 trillion of non-financial debt. Add to that tens of trillions more of global non-financial equity looking for a place to invest and you can see just how enormous the flood of money available to invest in stocks has become. The challenge of earning decent returns on capital is exacerbated by the imposition of historically low interest rates by central banks. With bonds serving as certificates of confiscation that guarantee negative returns for years to come, money is naturally drawn to stocks that at least offer the prospect of positive returns.

Markets are currently celebrating the election of a pro-business Republican to replace an anti-business Democrat in the White House. But while a more economically enlightened policy environment may offer a reasonable basis for buying stocks, the structural factors outlined above that favor money flowing into stocks make an even more powerful case. Even if US stocks struggle with higher interest rates and a strong dollar, the gravitational pull of enormous amounts of capital looking for decent returns into a shrinking pool of stocks may make it much more difficult for a sharp sell-off to occur, certainly one that would last very long before all that money would come back into the market looking for “bargains.”

I see only one thing that might stop this strong gravitational pull in the near future.

Stocks Have One Weak Spot – The 10-Year Treasury Yield

Right now, the biggest danger to stocks appears to be higher interest rates. Most observers (at least the ones I respect) put the danger zone at the 10-year Treasury hitting 3%. I actually think the market could keep going until that yield hits 3.25-3.5% provided higher rates are seen as a sign of better economic growth. The Fed is telling people it plans to raise rates three times in 2017, an aggressive stance to which it is unlikely to stand up. But even 50 basis points (two hikes) would push 10-year yields close to 3% and closer to the day of reckoning.

With American corporations carrying more debt than on the verge of the financial crisis in 2008, higher rates will worry investors. And with total nonfinancial debt in the US hitting $69.4 trillion at the end of the third quarter of 2016 (excluding unfunded entitlements), higher rates will suck hundreds of billions of dollars out of the economy to pay interest (every 1% rise in interest rates costs the economy nearly $700 billion).

The yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury is already up more than 50 basis points since the election and is almost twice its post-Brexit low last July. The only thing standing in the way of the next upward move is another weakening in the economy, which would also not bode well for stock prices if it materialized.

But until rates hit the danger zone, the structural situation where enormous amounts of money are available to invest in a diminishing number of stocks will remain a strong force supporting the market. That doesn’t mean stocks are guaranteed to produce positive returns in 2017, just that the odds of anything worse than a garden variety bear market (down 10%) are limited. Further, all that money chasing the limited number of stocks will likely render any bear market short-lived, especially since investors are trained to “buy dips” since the financial crisis.

Of course, this doesn’t mean a lot of stocks won’t still go down – there are many lousy companies trading at unsustainable levels. It remains a stock picker’s market on both the long and short side, but the structural forces supporting the market appear pretty potent for the moment.

Last week, markets were pretty quiet with the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropping 78.07 points or -0.4% to 19,885.73 and the S&P 500 dropping 0.1% to 2274.64. The Nasdaq Composite Index gained 1% to a record high 5574.12 as investors continued to buy stocks like Facebook, Inc. (FB),, Inc. (AMZN) and even the ridiculously overpriced and highly unprofitable Tesla Motors, Inc. (TSLA). The yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury ended the week at 2.398% and the US Dollar Index dropped to 101.19.

With the inauguration coming on Friday, Congress is already taking steps to repeal the disastrous and unaffordable Obamacare law and with a little luck President Trump will wipe a slew of anti-growth regulations off the books within the first 100 days of his presidency. This should provide a positive backdrop for a market that is already benefitting from record levels of bullishness.

For the moment, betting against all of this optimism, especially with the powerful structural forces described above at work, would seem to be unwise. Our overpriced markets will likely see a correction but it may not come until later this year after rates rise further.



17 Responses to “This Is The Only Number That Can “Switch Off” The Bull Market”

  1. Lucid & rational analysis, that factors in current irrational circumstances with long term fundamentals. As an old Howard Ruff subscriber, I’ve been waiting for about a quarter century for the “ship to hit the sand” & it looks like it’s gonna happen.

  2. In the next few days we will see George Soros finally let the number go over 20,000. It is impossible to believe that it has hovered so close for so long and has not accidentally gone over. The reason is so that Obama will forever will be the president who took the market over 20,000. Then it will do a massive crash which he will control and will make billions off of that everyone will blame on Trump. Then he will enjoy the rebound and make more billions but will control it so that Trump cannot claim any benefit. I predict this will be a done deal by Tuesday of next week so you will soon know if I am an idiot or not.

  3. I agree. Also adding to the stance is all the corporate buy-backs of stock that have happened since 2009. For example, at one time INTC has over 6 Billion shares of stock outstanding. Now they are at some 4.8 Billion – a 20% reduction of shares available to the investing public.

  4. Scores of analysts have claimed that they predicted “accurately” the “great depression of 2008.” The same analysts have been predicting the demise of the stock market in the last few years, even giving actual times for it to happen. All those dates have come and gone, but when it actually happens they will claim again that they predicted it “accurately.” Go figure!

  5. Not so fast!! The 10 year Treasury is starting to fall again!!. Interest rates simply can not go up as it will crash the share market and housing market. No politician is going to see that on their watch. There are too many factors at play leading to deflation – baby boomer retiring, falling productivity, underemployment, increasing numbers on welfare, declining middle class, falling education standards, automation etc etc.

Leave a Comment

View this page online: